How to Watch Aurora Teagarden Mysteries in Order

If you’re ready to dive into a world of mystery and intrigue, the Aurora Teagarden Mysteries offer a captivating journey. You follow Aurora Teagarden, affectionately known as Roe, a librarian turned amateur detective. This series, based on Charlaine Harris’s books, takes you to the quaint town of Lawrenceton, Washington. Here, Aurora leads the Real Murders Club, where true crime enthusiasts gather to explore historical cases, only to find themselves entangled in real-life mysteries.

With 18 movies released since 2015, you have the chance to watch Aurora solve cases with wit and determination. From the first film, “A Bone to Pick,” to the latest installments, these stories offer a cozy yet exciting atmosphere. Candace Cameron Bure’s portrayal of Aurora adds charm and depth, making it a delightful series for those who love a good mystery.

1. Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Something New

IMDb Rating: 6.2/10 | Rotten Tomatoes Rating: 26%

When you watch Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: A Fresh Start, you’re diving into a new chapter of the beloved series. Released on June 9, 2023, this film marks the beginning without Candace Cameron Bure in the lead role of Aurora Teagarden. Instead, Skyler Samuels steps into the shoes of a younger Aurora, giving you a fresh perspective as the story unfolds.

The movie, directed by Jessica Harmon, spans 84 minutes and focuses on Aurora returning to her hometown, Lawrenceton, after college. She aims to continue her studies, but soon you find her caught up in a mystery involving Sally’s fiancée. As a viewer, you’ll notice that while the familiar mysterious ambiance is still present, there are some changes in character portrayals that might feel new.

The cast is robust, with talents like Marilu Henner, Evan Roderick, and Kayla Heller contributing to the narrative. Despite the shift in characters, the film retains the series’ cozy vibe that you’ve come to appreciate. This installment suggests that even with changes, the series continues to offer intriguing plots. If you’re a fan, there’s a lot to discover and enjoy in this new take on Aurora’s adventures.

2. Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Haunted by Murder

IMDb Rating: 7.1/10

Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Haunted by Murder takes you on a thrilling investigation in the town of Lawrenceton. Directed by Martin Wood, this film brings back the excitement of a classic mystery in the series. The story revolves around Aurora and Sally, who once, as teenagers, discovered a body in a house with a spooky reputation. This unsettling memory from their past resurfaces when they decide to revisit the house.

The movie features a talented cast, including Candace Cameron Bure and Niall Matter. Other notable actors include Marilu Henner, Lexa Doig, and Peter Benson. The film lasts for 84 minutes, ensuring a compact yet captivating mystery experience.

The plot focuses on how Aurora and her friends deal with the reopened investigation in a house rumored to be haunted. This narrative diverges from the romance-centered previous films, returning to a captivating mystery. Haunted by Murder fits into a unique niche, as Hallmark tends to focus more on Christmas-themed films, making this horror-esque story stand out.

In this installment, you’re drawn into the eccentric world of amateur detectives, each with their own quirks and intelligence. The film balances suspense and character development, keeping you engaged. Whether you’re a seasoned fan or new to the series, this movie offers an intriguing and entertaining mystery set against the backdrop of small-town lore. With its engaging plot and skilled performances, it invites you to explore the secrets lurking within Lawrenceton.

3. Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Honeymoon, Honeymurder

IMDb Rating: 6.8/10

In Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Honeymoon, Honeymurder, you follow Aurora and Nick on their special “pre-honeymoon” trip. Set on August 22, 2021, this mystery unfolds as they stay in a snug cabin that offers a break from modern conveniences. The cabin’s simple charm adds to the warmth of the movie. During an evening boat ride on a peaceful lake, the couple stumbles upon a body floating in the water.

Although Aurora hesitates to let this discovery disrupt their time away, she and Nick ultimately decide they are best positioned to investigate. The movie is approximately 84 minutes long, directed by Martin Wood, and features a cast that includes Candace Cameron Bure, Niall Matter, and Marilu Henner, among others.

There’s a distinct difference in this installment due to COVID-19 constraints, with a small ensemble cast set in a secluded area. This setting amplifies the mystery, providing an interesting twist from other films in the series. Watching Aurora unravel the enigma maintains its appeal, putting her skills as a detective front and center. The uniqueness lies in the confined setting and how it changes the dynamics of the mystery-solving process.

4. Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Til Death Do Us Part

IMDb Rating: 7.1/10

Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Til Death Do Us Part premiered on June 13, 2021, under the direction of Martin Wood. This mystery film stands out with its intriguing plot and well-rounded cast. The movie stars Candace Cameron Bure as Aurora, alongside Niall Matter, Marilu Henner, and Lexa Doig. At 84 minutes long, it delivers a compact yet engaging storyline.

The plot kicks off as Aurora and Nick prepare for their upcoming wedding. During this time, their lives take a surprising turn when they discover a skull. This unsettling find becomes even more critical when Aurora realizes her father might be a suspect. The movie builds tension as Aurora must race against time to clear her father’s name just days before he is supposed to walk her down the aisle.

Despite the initial tension, there’s a certainty that Aurora’s father isn’t the culprit. This knowledge doesn’t detract from the film’s excitement. Instead, it adds layers to the story, building anticipation for the wedding. The movie beautifully depicts themes of love and trust between Aurora and Nick, emphasizing how their relationship thrives amidst the chaos. The wedding scenes promise a fulfilling pay-off for viewers, marking this film as a memorable addition to the Aurora Teagarden series.

5. Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: How to Con a Con

IMDb Rating: 7.0/10

Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: How to Con a Con, released on March 14, 2021, adds a fresh twist to the beloved series. The film is directed by Tony Dean Smith and lasts 84 minutes. The story follows Aurora, played by Candace Cameron Bure, and her fiancé Nick as they try to solve a murder. Aurora’s mother, Aida, discovers a grisly crime when one of her real estate clients turns up dead.

The cast features familiar faces like Niall Matter, Marilu Henner, and Lexa Doig. Other actors include Peter Benson, Miranda Frigon, and Dylan Sloane. The narrative unfolds with the Real Murders Club stepping in. Aurora and Nick take on the challenge of uncovering the truth behind a complex con.

This installment shows Aurora at her sharpest. Despite some setbacks, her ingenuity is clear. The plot is intricate, featuring believable yet diverse suspects. Aurora’s methods bring a new and unusual approach to capturing the con artist responsible.

Phillip, a character often suspected in past movies, gets involved and contributes to the detective work. The dynamic between the characters adds layers to the story, keeping you engaged. This movie presents a mix of cleverness and surprise, offering a fresh perspective on crime solving that keeps you guessing until the end.

6. Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Reunited and It Feels So Deadly

IMDb Rating: 6.9/10

Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Reunited and It Feels So Deadly, released on October 18, 2020 and directed by Martin Wood, introduces a mix of suspense and nostalgia. You are drawn into a high school reunion unlike any other. Aurora and Nick, newly engaged, attend Aurora’s 20th high school reunion. Things take a dark turn when Jack Landon, the former prom king, is discovered in the pool with a knife plunged into his back.

The cast, featuring stars like Candace Cameron Bure, Niall Matter, and Marilu Henner, shines in their roles. Bure and Matter’s chemistry adds depth to Aurora and Nick’s relationship. The movie runs for 84 minutes, keeping you hooked with its evolving mystery and personal dynamics.

With Aurora and Nick, you explore the intricacies of old high school friendships and rivalries. Each classmate seems to have a reason to see Jack gone, adding layers to the investigation. The high school setting provides a fresh backdrop, bringing life to the series with new characters and old tensions. However, you notice an interesting twist where the true murderer appears somewhat obvious, yet Aurora remains oblivious.

This episode enriches the series with its unique setting, intriguing mystery, and a touch of romance. Whether you’re a fan of cozy mysteries or just curious, you’re likely to appreciate how this installment keeps you guessing till the end.

7. Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Heist and Seek

IMDb Rating: 6.9/10

On May 17, 2020, Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Heist and Seek was released. Directed by Peter Benson, this film centers around a gripping mystery involving a stolen crown. During a benefit gala at the library where Aurora works, a valuable crown goes missing. Aurora, along with the Real Murders Club, dives into solving this intriguing heist.

The cast includes well-known actors such as Candace Cameron Bure, Niall Matter, and Marilu Henner, among others. With a runtime of 85 minutes, the movie ensures plenty of thrilling twists and turns for mystery enthusiasts.

One of the unique aspects of this installment is its focus on character dynamics. You see distinct characters like Lexa Doig and others interacting in new and interesting ways, making for engaging scenes. While Aurora is busy solving the mystery, Nick faces a different challenge. He wrestles with finding the right moment to propose to Aurora, adding a romantic subplot to the story.

The proposal itself adds charm and warmth, reminiscent of a classic Hallmark romance. Fans of the Aurora Teagarden series will find this movie particularly enjoyable due to its clever blend of mystery and personal stories, maintaining both suspense and heartwarming elements throughout.

8. Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: A Very Foul Play

IMDb Rating: 7.0/10

In Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: A Very Foul Play, you follow Aurora and the Real Murders Club as they stage a play in Lawrenceton. Things unexpectedly spiral when a real-life murder takes place during the performance. From this moment, a captivating investigation unfolds.

Phillip, already implicated in prior incidents, finds himself accused again, and it’s up to you to join Aurora in clearing his name. The probe into this murder combines intriguing elements and complex storytelling.

The film adds depth by showcasing Detective Lynn Smith, portrayed by Miranda Frigon. In this installment, she becomes more of a collaborator than an adversary, which marks a fresh take on the dynamic between the police and the Real Murders Club.

9. Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: An Inheritance to Die For

IMDb Rating: 7.0/10

In Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: An Inheritance to Die For, you find yourself following the story of Aurora as she navigates a complex situation. This film, which came out on August 11, 2019, is directed by Michael Robison and runs for 84 minutes. It features a talented cast, including Candace Cameron Bure, Niall Matter, and Marilu Henner, among others.

The mystery begins with a suspicious poisoning at a wedding, leading Aurora to investigate the circumstances around Gladys McCourt’s death. Several individuals could benefit from Gladys’s questionable will, sparking a flurry of accusations among them. You can picture yourself trying to piece together the puzzle with Aurora, as she has to uncover who really wanted Gladys gone.

Amidst this, Aurora’s personal life adds another layer to the story. Her relationship with Nick becomes strained as he feels she’s distancing herself. You’ll see Aurora juggling her feelings, making tough choices about their future together. The storyline weaves a blend of mystery and personal dilemmas, capturing your attention as Aurora and Nick eventually solve the case, strengthening their bond in the process.

10. Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: A Game of Cat and Mouse

IMDb Rating: 7.1/10

In Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: A Game of Cat and Mouse, you find yourself diving into a story filled with intrigue and tension. The tale begins with a break-in at the Real Murders Club, where cryptic clues are left behind, just waiting to be unraveled. Each clue is tied to famous quotes from mystery novels, sparking the curiosity of Aurora Teagarden. Partnering with Nick and his colleague Bree, played by Tammy Gillis, you journey through a labyrinth of possibilities to uncover the truth.

As you follow Aurora and her friends, you’ll notice that the case is more than just another mystery. The break-in seems personal, driven by jealousy toward the close rapport between Nick and Aurora. This element adds layers of complexity, making you question and speculate about the motives behind each character’s actions.

Imagine yourself piecing together the puzzle as potential suspects cross your path, each with their motives and secrets. The thrill of deduction is matched by a budding romance between Aurora and Nick, adding a layer of warmth to the suspenseful narrative. As the film unfolds, you witness the resolution of their romantic tension, offering a satisfying conclusion to their developing relationship.

With a runtime of 83 minutes and a cast that includes Candace Cameron Bure, Marilu Henner, and Niall Matter, this movie presents an engaging mix of mystery, intrigue, and romance.

11. Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: The Disappearing Game

IMDb Rating: 6.7/10 | Rotten Tomatoes Rating: 40%

This entry in the Aurora Teagarden series first aired on April 15, 2018, with Terry Ingram at the helm. At the heart of this film is Aurora, played by Candace Cameron Bure, who is joined by Marilu Henner, Niall Matter, and a host of other talented actors including Lexa Doig, Peter Benson, and James Rittinger. The runtime of this movie is 83 minutes.

In Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: The Disappearing Game, Aurora’s family is highlighted through the introduction of her cousin, Phillip, portrayed by Dylan Sloan. The story takes a mysterious turn when both Phillip and his roommate vanish following the puzzling death of the roommate’s girlfriend. This disappearance prompts Aurora to dive into the mystery, seeking assistance from her circle of friends as well as Nick Miller, played by Niall Matter. Nick, a college professor who recently moved to Aurora’s neighborhood, immediately catches her eye.

The film not only advances the storyline by introducing Phillip to the viewers but also marks the beginning of a significant romantic journey for Aurora and Nick. The chemistry between Candace Cameron Bure and Niall Matter is palpable, setting the stage for future developments in the series.

12. Reap What You Sew: An Aurora Teagarden Mystery

IMDb Rating: 6.8/10

In Reap What You Sew: An Aurora Teagarden Mystery, you dive into an engaging crime story. Aurora Teagarden, played by Candace Cameron Bure, takes center stage to unravel another mystery. This time, her old friend Poppy Wilson returns to town with an exciting online business venture. Yet, her return is marked by tragedy when she is found dead. Poppy’s success in her field brought her many admirers and many enemies, making the list of suspects quite extensive.

Without a romantic subplot taking the spotlight, the focus is squarely on unraveling the crime. This approach harkens back to the earlier Aurora Teagarden mysteries, allowing you to fully immerse yourself in the puzzle-solving. The absence of personal relationship issues lets you experience a purer, more direct mystery. This streamlined narrative breathes new life into Aurora’s investigative skills, showcasing her knack for solving complex cases without unnecessary interruptions.

13. Last Scene Alive: An Aurora Teagarden Mystery

IMDb Rating: 6.8/10

In this movie, a film crew arrives in Lawrenceton to turn a book by Robin Daniels into a feature film. The book is inspired by a person very much like Aurora Teagarden, a librarian with a taste for solving mysteries. The twist begins when the actress set to portray “Aurora” is found dead, and the real Aurora must delve into the mystery to unveil the culprit from the film crew.

Additional cast members include Miranda Frigon, Peter Benson, and Ellie Harvie, among others. Each actor plays an integral part in bringing the gripping story to life.

This film is the seventh installment in the Aurora Teagarden series. It also marks a significant point in the storyline, as it’s the last appearance of Martin, Aurora’s romantic interest. Martin finds himself embroiled in a personal situation as he becomes worried about his former CIA colleague’s disappearance. His journey eventually takes him away from Lawrenceton as he leaves for South America, hoping to track down his missing partner. This decision brings about a turning point for both Martin and Aurora, closing a chapter in the series.

14. A Bundle of Trouble: An Aurora Teagarden Mystery

IMDb Rating: 6.6/10 | Rotten Tomatoes Rating: 61%

Released on May 21, 2017, A Bundle of Trouble: An Aurora Teagarden Mystery stands out as the first in the series not drawn from Harris’ original books. Directed by Kevin Fair, this movie explores a unique storyline that centers around Regina, played by Carly McKillip. Regina, who is Martin’s niece, unexpectedly shows up at Aurora’s door. Her sudden appearance becomes even more mysterious when she leaves behind not just her infant but also the body of her husband.

The film pushes into dramatic territory, reminiscent of soap operas, due to its unconventional plot twists, likely due to having no Harris novel to adapt. Despite this, the dynamic between Aurora and Martin remains compelling, offering a deeper look into their developing relationship. This installment gives Martin, played by Yannick Bisson, more screen presence, allowing viewers to see more of his character’s depth and the chemistry he shares with Aurora. This shift adds a refreshing layer to the ongoing narrative.

15. The Julius House: An Aurora Teagarden Mystery

IMDb Rating: 6.9/10 | Rotten Tomatoes Rating: 50%

Released on March 19, 2017, “The Julius House: An Aurora Teagarden Mystery” is directed by Terry Ingram. This film features a star-studded cast, including Candace Cameron Bure, Yannick Bisson, and Lexa Doig, among others, delivering a runtime of 84 minutes.

The story kicks off with the shocking murder of Captain Jack Burns, played by Craig March. Despite the rocky history between Aurora (Candace Cameron Bure) and the captain, she is determined to unravel the mystery behind his death. As the plot thickens, Aurora’s life takes another twist—a break-in at her house and a puzzling gift add layers to the unfolding drama.

This chapter in the Aurora Teagarden Mystery series focuses not just on solving crimes, but on relationships as well. You watch as Aurora and her significant other, Martin, navigate the complexities of their nearly one-year-long relationship. The stress of these developments is palpable, adding emotional depth to the storyline.

Meanwhile, Aurora takes a personal interest in playing matchmaker for her friend Sally. This attempt to set Sally up with one of Martin’s colleagues adds a touch of everyday life, giving the film a relatable edge. Even though the core mystery isn’t the tightest in the series, the focus on character dynamics provides a satisfying experience.

16. Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Three Bedrooms, One Corpse

IMDb Rating: 6.7/10 | Rotten Tomatoes Rating: 44%

In Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Three Bedrooms, One Corpse, Aurora takes on real estate as a new career path. Unfortunately, showing houses turns dark when bodies start turning up, making it clear that a killer is on the loose. You see Aurora working alongside her Real Murder Club friends, John Queensland and Perry Dell, to uncover which of her colleagues might be behind these crimes.

This movie is directed by Lynne Stopkewich and was released on June 12, 2016. It features a robust cast, including Candace Cameron Bure, Lexa Doig, Marilu Henner, and Yannick Bisson. Bisson’s character, Martin Bartell, is introduced as a love interest for Aurora, adding complexity to their relationship across future films.

With a runtime of 84 minutes, the story presents a blend of mystery and suspense and even throws in elements of art theft, keeping you intrigued. The evolving narrative and character dynamics contribute to its appeal, ensuring you remain engaged throughout the film.

This film marks a significant point in the series, combining mystery and personal relationships that are central to its charm.

17. Real Murders: An Aurora Teagarden Mystery

IMDb Rating: 6.8/10 | Rotten Tomatoes Rating: 45%

In the first movie from the Aurora Teagarden series, the plot revolves around a group of crime enthusiasts coming together at your local library for the debut gathering of the Real Murders Club. The event takes a dark turn when one of the attendees is found dead, mimicking the method of murder planned to be discussed that evening. You are immersed in a world of mystery as Aurora employs her keen investigative skills to prove her innocence and prevent further tragedies.

The series takes a notable shift from the first to the second film, as fresh faces come into play, adding depth and intriguing twists to the storylines. The scope broadens significantly, offering a more expansive narrative with complex characters. Unlike other Hallmark films, this series doesn’t shy away from exploring more intense and darker themes, making each installment more suspenseful.

18. Aurora Teagarden Mystery: A Bone to Pick

IMDb Rating: 6.6/10 | Rotten Tomatoes Rating: 59%

Aurora Teagarden Mystery: A Bone to Pick centers on Aurora Teagarden, a librarian with a knack for solving mysteries. Released on April 4, 2015, and directed by Martin Wood, this film kicks off the Hallmark mystery series. With a runtime of 83 minutes, you will see Aurora in Lawrenceton, Washington, where she inherits a house from an old friend. This gift comes with something unexpected—a hidden skull. Aurora is left wondering if her friend was involved in a crime and if it’s her job to prove her innocence.

The movie stars Candace Cameron Bure as the lively and determined Aurora. The cast also includes Lexa Doig, Marilu Henner, and Bruce Dawson. Throughout the film, Aurora receives not just the house, but also money and jewelry from the estate. Yet, it’s the mystery of the skull that pulls you into the story, making you question who the skull belonged to and why it was hidden.

As the series begins with this film, much of it is about setting up the world Aurora lives in. You see how Aurora transitions from a curious librarian to an amateur detective, eager to uncover the truth. The early setting might feel smaller compared to the adventures that follow in the series, but it is filled with engaging twists and turns. The casting of Candace Cameron Bure as Aurora is spot-on, with her cheerful demeanor making the investigation feel both light-hearted and intriguing, capturing your attention and leaving you eager for the next mystery.

Frequently Asked Questions